In
Copyright Since September 11,
2000
This
web site is
in no manner
affiliated with any Kaiser entity and the for profit Permanente
Permission
is granted to mirror this web site -
Please acknowledge where the material was obtained.
ABOUT US |
CONTACT
|
MCRC
kaiserpapers.com/seniors
This is a press release sent out by:
Physicians for Compassionate Care
P.O. Box 6042
Portland, Oregon 97228
(503) 533-8154; Fax (503) 533-0429; www.pccef.org
PRESS
RELEASE
August 15, 2002
HMO
SEEKS OUT ASSISTED-SUICIDE
DOCTORS
In an
electronic memorandum dated
August 6, 2002,
Kaiser Permanente NW, an HMO in Oregon where assisted suicide has been
legalized, claimed it is difficult to find doctors to give lethal
overdoses
to patients. So Janet
P. Price, representing
Northwest
Permanente, sent a memorandum to 829 recipients requesting that all
doctors
willing to overdose
patients give their name to Doctor
Robert Richardson of the
Ethics
Service or to another Kaiser administrator.
The memorandum
complained that
Richardson’s Ethics
Service could not find a doctor to give deadly drugs to a patient who
was
“suffering” and dying for three weeks. The communication did
not
explain why the patient’s suffering was not adequately treated and
relieved
for three weeks or what Kaiser Permanente proposes to do to improve its
pain treatment and palliative care.
Doctor Richardson is the same doctor-administrator
who
approved the
overdosing of HMO patient Kate
Cheney,
despite the fact that Mrs. Cheney had been determined to be demented,
under
pressure from her family, and therefore not eligible for assisted
suicide.
Some individuals have speculated that cost savings could be one
motivating
factor stimulating HMO administrators to provide so much support for
assisted
suicide.
The entire
contents of the original
memorandum follow:
“Kaiser Permanente Northwest Division
ELECTRONIC MEMORANDUM
Sent:
06-Aug-2002 01:21pm
PDT
From:
Janet P. Price
PRICEJANETP
Dept:
Northwest Permanente
Tel No:
49-2657
TO: See Below
Subject: Oregon Death with Dignity
Act:
Physician Participation
IF YOU ARE NOT INTERESTED IN PARTICIPATING PLEASE
DISREGARD THIS E-MAIL
OREGON DEATH WITH DIGNITY ACT: PHYSICIAN
PARTICIPATION
KPNW has complied with implementation of
the Oregon
Death with Dignity
Act (for Oregon residents ONLY) since it became law. The use
of
this
law by KPNW patients and physicians has been administered by our
Regional
Ethics Service. Recently our Ethics Service had a situation
where
no attending MD could be found to assist an eligible member in
implementing
the law for three weeks, during which time this person was suffering
and
actively dying.
Participation by physicians is completely
voluntary. At times
a member’s primary care or specialist physician is unwilling
to participate in this process. If this
happens,
the Ethics Service approaches the Chief of the primary or specialty
care service involved with this member, to
identify another
physician willing to participate. Significant time
is often lost because some Chiefs do not know which
of their
physicians are willing to volunteer. This can be very
distressing to critically ill patients and their
families.
THE
RESPONSIBILITIES OF AN ATTENDING
PHYSICIAN:
Using questions required by the law,
interview the
patient to determine
whether he or she is appropriate to proceed with a request for
medication
to end life (a clinic or home visit is usually necessary for this)
.
There must be a second discussion with the patient in person or by
phone
a minimum of 15 days after first request confirming this request.
If the attending physician agrees to
support the
request, the Ethics
Service will arrange an appointment with a non Kaiser physician to
independently
evaluate the patient and his or her request.
If the attending and the consulting
physician agree
that the request
is reasonable, the Ethics Service will arrange for a designated Kaiser
Pharmacist to assist the attending physician in writing the
prescription
for appropriate medications. The pharmacist will dispense and
explain
their use to the patient and caregiver.
A representative of the Oregon Health
Division will
contact by phone
the attending physician after the patient’s death to confirm the
process
and the manner of the patient’s death. This takes about 10
minutes.
The Ethics Service guides Physicians
through this
process and makes
all necessary arrangements for other requirements of the law.
QUESTIONS TO
PHYSICIANS:
Are you willing to act as the Attending
Physician
under the law for
YOUR patient?
Are you willing to act as the Attending
Physician
under the law for
members who ARE NOT your patients?
IF YOU ARE WILLING TO PARTICIPATE IN
EITHER # 1
AND/OR #2, Please
e-mail or call Marcia L. Liberson, MPH (LIBERSONMA, 49-3781) or Robert
H. Richardson, MD (503-904-7978), KPNW Ethics
Service.
For questions please contact either Marcia or
Robert.
Thank you.
IF YOU ARE NOT INTERESTED IN
PARTICIPATING PLEASE
DISREGARD THIS
E-MAIL.
TO:
829 addressees
CC:
2 addressees”
*************************************************************************************************
kaiserpapers.com/seniors
kaiserpapers.com
|