The Manipulation of HMO Medical Testing by Charles Phillips, MD FACP

The Kaiser Papers A Public Service Web Site

In Copyright Since September 11, 2000
This web site is in no manner affiliated with any Kaiser entity and the for profit Permanente.
Permission is granted to mirror if credit to the author is given.

Link for Translation of the Kaiser Papers

| ABOUT US | CONTACT | | MCRC

The Manipulation of HMO Medical Testing
By Charles Phillips, MD FACP - CPhil49401@aol.com
Fresno, California, April 22, 2003

XIII. Exhibits
#l - Kaiser Ads - the Promises:

     1a - website posting - "absolute.. trust";
       1b - Senior Advantage Ad - "we'd like to be there for you";
       1c - Another Senior Advantage Ad - "patient care comes first";
       1d A Third Senior Advantage Ad "secret opinion walking down the hallway";
       1e - A Fourth Senior Advantage Ad - "a plan you can trust"

#2 - "Patient" vs. "Customer" Detailed Essay;
#3 - Sample Cover of the Permanente Journal;
#4 - Kaiser Cartoon - why the lines will stay long;
#5 - Web Pathway and Article - "Selecting and Interpreting Diagnostic Tests" - and the table on Lyme's testing;
#6 - Abnormal Stress Test - read by Kaiser as "unremarkable";
#7 - Comparing Blood Counts:

        a. 7a - WBC - Kaiser - 1995 - Southern California;
        b. 7b - WBC - Kaiser - 1998 - Southern California;
        c. 7c - WBC - Kaiser - 2001 - Southern California;
      d. 7d - WBC - Kaiser - 1997 - Northern California (TPMG);
        e. 7e - WBC - Kaiser - 1998 - Northern California (TPMG);
        f.   7f - WBC - Kaiser - 1998 - Northern California (TMPC);
        g. 7g - WBC - Victor Valley Hospital;
        h. 7h - WBC - National Standard - not Kaiserized;
        i.   7i - WBC - National Standard

#8 - Renal Tests - Northern California - creatinine - upper limit set too high.
#9- Lyme Tests

        a. 9a-Topic Introduction ;
        b. 9b - Overview by Miguel Perez-Lizano;
        c. 9c - Kaiser's Lyme protocol - now taken offline by Kaiser;
        d. 9d - Dr. Donta's published protocol on Lyme - Boston;
        e. 9e - A Critique of Kaiser v. Dr. Donta ;
        f.   9f - One Lyme patient's experience with Kaiser;
        g. 9g - Another Patient's Experience;
        h. 9h -Yet Another Patient;
         i. 9i - $65,000 Award for Missed Lyme Disease and a Wrecked Life.

#10- Anthrax

a. l0a- Kaiser's Advice vs. that of the CDC;
b. l0b- Kaiser uses Anthrax Posting on Web to Recruit MDs

#11- Chest X-rays:

        a. 11a- Patient with CXR sent by outside ER;
        b. 11b-Kaiser Loses X-ray;
        c. 11c- Dramatized True Story - Kaiser Delays Ordering a Chest X-ray;
        d. 11d- Chest x-ray reading simply a checked box, not a description

#12- Underreading of MRIs

a. Contract Group Avoids Mentioning Cruciate Ligament and Minimizes Damage to the Meniscus Cartilage;

b. Correct Reading of the same MRI;

#13 - California Leads the Nation in HMO Penetration - [Bad News];
#14- Cover and page II of "The Evolution of Medical Groups and Capitation in California";
#15 - Fewer Physicians for More Patients

         a. Older Kaiser Doctors Pack their Bags;
         b. Physician Moves Away From Patients as More DistantTeam Leader
           Spin Picture to Look Like the Patient will have More Access;

#16- The Permanente Map;
#17 - Patients vs. Staff

17a. "External Customers" pictured as Drab People;
17b. Kaiser staff- pictured as a more elite group of people;

#18 - Kaiser's Dirty Little Secret;
#19 - Kaiser Colorado Spin on Physician Incentives;
#20 - Medicare Benefits Going Down;
#21 - Dr. Lawrence's Life Style:

     #21 a - $2,800,000 Home;
     #21 b Questionable Relationship to Watson Pharmacenticals;
     #21c -$14 Million Kaiser Investment for Caretouch, then Spinoff with Dr. Lawrence still on board;
     #21d - Home Forgiveness - "In Silicon Valley a new kind of house call"

#22 - Mr. Halvorson - Kaiser's New CEO - Caught with Huge Perks in Minnesota -Fooling his own Staff;
#23 - Bayer/Kaiser Fraud - Scheming to Defraud the Government on Cipro;
#24 - Kaiser Uses 990 to Emphasize Non-profit images with for profit physicians obscured;
#25 - Kaiser Tries to Look Benevolent (no KP stocks);
#26 - The Permanente Medical Group Clearly Has Stock;
#27 - My Own Physician Profile on the Kaiser Computer Note secret "Report Card" (that I'll never see);
#28 - Outcome Goes Down for the Poor and Elderly in Managed Care
#29 - Kaiser's Net Income $137 per Quarter - or $648 million a year (Now divide half of that among the 3000 Permanente partners) = $100,000+ per year in dividend from under treating and undertesting;
#30 - Kaiser Hints at Incentives but Down Plays the Amount Every Time;
#31 - Physicians Brag about being Part Owners;
#32 - The Tahoe Agreement;
#33 - Documents Disappear Easily at Kaiser - State Department of Corporation Investigator Notices.

Home

BACK TO INDEX OF SELECTED WRITINGS OF DR. CHARLES PHILLIPS